Is white bread better for teeth than wholewheat?

One of the clear results Lady May Mellanby’s extensive research on dental decay is what she referred to as “the cereal effect”.  Poorly mineralized teeth and tooth decay were more prevalent in both children and animals who consumed the greatest amount of cereal grains.

In diets that were deficient in vitamin D, puppies that were fed oatmeal as part of their diet developed the most defective teeth (poorly formed and poorly mineralized enamel and dentin).   Those receiving received white rice and white flour developed the best mineralized teeth.   Whole wheat flour was worse for teeth than white flour. Lady Mellanby showed that it was the amount of wheat germ in the flour that affected tooth development and calcification.  The anticalcifying agent in cereal grains could be largely, though not completely, countered with adequate intake of vitamin D.

In the diet trials with children, Lady Mellanby varied vitamin D, calcium and cereal content, and found the best results with those children who consumed a cereal-free diet, rich in vitamin D and calcium.  In these children almost no new cavities developed, and pre-existing cavities showed extensive hardening and healing.  This is in contrast to the children following vitamin D and calcium poor diets that contained extra servings of oatmeal.  Those children showed decreasing dental health with development of new cavities and no hardening or healing of existing cavities.

So what is the anticalcifying agent present in the cereal grains?  It was suspected, and later proved, to be phytic acid, or phytate, which is found naturally in nuts, seeds, and grains.  White rice and white flour have generally low levels of phytate, while whole wheat flour and oatmeal have higher levels.  When ingested, phytate can chemically bind in the gut with calcium and other minerals such as magnesium, iron and zinc, making them unavailable for absorption.  The minerals are excreted with the undigested fiber.  The effect of consuming fiber-rich cereal grains is the same as reducing the dietary intake of calcium and other minerals.

In Hawaii during the 1920’s rampant early childhood decay in the children of plantation workers was eliminated when traditional taro and sweet potatoes were substituted for the rice and bread that made up much of their diet. Taro and sweet potatoes are low in phytate.

We are all encouraged to consume more healthy, whole-grained, fiber-rich foods.  However, as Professor Harold Sandstead writes in 1992:

…it appears that some health promoters who suggest that US adults should consume 30-35 g dietary fiber daily have not done their homework or have simply ignored the carefully done research on this topic.  They appear to be unaware of the effects of phytate on mineral retention and the fact that many of the commonly consumed sources of fiber are rich in phytate, or to have been mislead by reports…[that] conclude that foods rich in fiber and phytate do not impair retention of essential minerals.”

Fortunately, for those who prefer to consume cereal grains, nuts and seeds the phytate content can be reduced by soaking, fermentation or longer rise times in breadmaking.  Nourishing Traditions by Sally Fallon provides an excellent introduction to this with recipes and directions.

About these ads
This entry was posted in Dental Researchers, May Mellanby, phytate, phytic acid, prevent cavities, tooth decay, Uncategorized, vitamin d. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Is white bread better for teeth than wholewheat?

  1. Pingback: Dr Mellanby’s Travels |

  2. František Koudelka says:

    i was eating a lot of white fluor as a child. that screwed up by teeth. so dentists filled my teeth with bunch of mercury and started my path towards chronic poisoning. it is a sad world we live in.

  3. Dawne Chartrand says:

    What a fascinating topic! Thank you for discussing phytic acid. This is an interesting link to help clinicians understand how complicated malabsorption syndromes can be. With Celiac disease, the intestines are damaged by exposure to gluten, reducing the ability to absorb nutrients. But that couldn’t completely account for the prevalence of osteoporotic tendencies in a large part of the Celiac population. The realization that phytic acid is an anticalcifying agent completes the understanding of the prevalence of osteoporosis, osteomalacia, and dental caries in the Celiac population. Thank you!!!

  4. Pete says:

    I have heard many things about the subject of wheat or grains. First I heard the majority of the wheat in the US was switched to a hybrid variety in the 1970’s. That change plus the harvest method or use of a combine may be responsible for the current epidemic of negative health effects related to it. It used to be that wheat was cut and piled in the fields as sheaves and left there a few days during this time the dew settled on them and the wheat seed transformed in some way. On the topic of whole wheat unless freshly ground it goes rancid quickly, that is to say the oils, in the germ I think it is, oxidize and at that point are unhealthy to consume. However many Americans don’t recognize the taste of rancid oils or food chemists find ways to deodorize and mask off flavors. I remember Weston Price gave whole wheat rolls to the children in his study and he did state the wheat was freshly cracked or ground. He also combined the wheat with milk and high vitamin butter oil. I also heard combining butter with bread makes it “healthier” can’t remember where I heard that and that toasted bread is better for you that non toasted, I think that is Aruvedic. That is not to mention all of the additives and preservatives in wheat products. I have heard two heirloom varieties are Einkorn and Emmer. While searching for the spelling of these I came across this heirloom seed site http://www.saltspringseeds.com/catalog/index.cfm?categoryid=34. Agricultural innovator Bruce Tainio said before corn was hybridized in the 1970’s it used to contain B12. This year there is a CSA that is offering heirloom wheat spouted and made into sourdough loves. I am working on curing my tooth decay and am not sure yet if I will partake in this bread that seems to be as non harming as bread can get… Thanks for this article.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s